Why Tenants Should Not Perform Their Own Maintenance

John Doss • February 16, 2025

As a landlord, it may be tempting to allow tenants to handle their own maintenance and repairs. While this might sound like a cost-effective solution, it can lead to numerous problems an potential liabilities. Here's why you should think twice before letting tenants take on maintenance responsibilities.


Lack of Expertise and Quality Control

Improperly performed maintenance can create serious safety risks for both the occupants and the property. This can expose you to significant liability concerns.

  • Tenant injuries during repair attempts could lead to legal action against the landlord.
  • Improper repairs might cause property damage, resulting in costlier fixes.
  • Electrical work performed by untrained individuals increases risk of fires or electrocution.
  • Structural repairs done incorrectly may compromise the building's integrity.

To avoid these issues, its important to use a trained professional who is insured and competent.


Difficulty in Tracking and Documenting Repairs

When tenants handle their own maintenance, it becomes challenging for landlords to:

  • Keep accurate records of repairs and maintenance history.
  • Ensure that all necessary maintenance is being performed regularly.
  • Verify the quality and completeness of repair work.

Proper documentation is crucial for property management, future sales, and potential legal disputes.


One of the primary reasons to avoid tenant-performed maintenance is the potential lack of skill and knowledge. Many tenants, despite good intentions, may not possess the necessary expertise to properly diagnose and fix issues. This can result in:

  • Subpar workmanship leading to more significant problems down the line.
  • Incomplete repairs that fail to address the root cause of the issue.
  • Misdiagnosis of problems, potentially exacerbating the original issue.

Professional maintenance ensures that repairs are done correctly the first time, saving money and preventing future complications.


Strain on Landlord-Tenant Relationships

Allowing tenants to perform maintenance can lead to conflicts and misunderstandings. Issues that may arise include:

  • Disagreements over the quality or necessity of repairs
  • Disputes over reimbursement for materials or time spent on maintenance
  • Tension when tenant-performed repairs fail or cause additional problems

Maintaining a professional approach to maintenance helps preserve positive landlord-tenant relationships.


While it may seem cost-effective to have tenants handle their own maintenance, the risks far outweigh the potential benefits. From liability concerns and safety hazards to quality control issues and legal compliance, there are numerous reasons to rely on professional maintenance services. By investing in proper property upkeep, landlords can protect their assets, ensure tenant safety, and maintain positive relationships with their renters. Ultimately, professional maintenance is a crucial aspect of responsible property management that should not be compromised.

By John Doss April 28, 2025
The “Buy, Borrow, Die” strategy has become a cornerstone of tax-efficient wealth-building for savvy real estate investors. This approach, popularized by tax law professor Edward McCaffery, allows individuals to grow, leverage, and transfer wealth while minimizing tax liabilities. In this guide, we’ll explore how this strategy works in real estate, its benefits and risks, and how to implement it effectively. 
By John Doss April 20, 2025
For savvy real estate investors, building wealth isn’t just about buying and selling properties—it’s about maximizing returns, minimizing taxes, and making every dollar work harder. Two of the most powerful tools for achieving these goals are 1031 exchanges and reverse 1031 exchanges. When used strategically, these exchanges can supercharge portfolio growth and play a critical role in the popular “buy, borrow, die” generational wealth-building strategy. Here’s what every investor should know. 
By John Doss April 13, 2025
As a landlord or tenant, ensuring transparency and accountability during the rental process is essential for maintaining a positive relationship and avoiding disputes. One of the most effective tools to achieve this is the property assessment form, completed at both the start and end of each tenancy. This document serves as a detailed record of the property’s condition, protecting both parties and setting clear expectations. At Doss & Spaulding Properties, we strongly enforce this practice, and in this blog, we’ll explain why it’s in everyone’s best interest to make property assessments a standard part of your leasing process. 
By John Doss April 6, 2025
Investing in single-family rentals or small multifamily properties can be a great way to build wealth, but success starts with thorough due diligence. Before signing on the dotted line, it’s essential to uncover potential risks and ensure the property aligns with your investment goals. At Doss & Spaulding Properties, we’ve created this concise checklist to guide you through the key areas to investigate before purchasing your next rental property.
By John Doss March 30, 2025
The Essential Professional Services Every Landlord Needs
By John Doss March 23, 2025
At Doss & Spaulding Properties, we prioritize the safety and satisfaction of tenants, ensuring they find homes without unnecessary stress or risk. Unfortunately, rental scams are a growing concern in today's competitive housing market, and we want to empower renters with the knowledge to protect themselves. In this article, we’ll explore common rental scams, red flags to watch for, and actionable tips to avoid falling victim. Rental scams occur when fraudsters deceive prospective tenants by advertising fake properties or posing as landlords to steal money or personal information. These scams can result in financial loss, identity theft, or wasted time and energy. Being informed is your first line of defense against these schemes.
By John Doss March 16, 2025
Selling a property that is currently occupied by tenants presents unique opportunities and challenges. While it can be an attractive proposition for certain buyers, it may also limit your options or complicate the sales process. Below, we explore the pros and cons of keeping a tenant in place while selling your home.
By John Doss March 9, 2025
North Carolina's Landlord-Friendly Rental Market: A Comprehensive Guide for Property Owners
By John Doss March 2, 2025
As a tenant, you may encounter various maintenance issues during your tenancy. This comprehensive guide addresses frequently asked questions about common problems and provides practical solutions to help you navigate these challenges effectively.
By John Doss February 23, 2025
As a landlord or property manager, rejecting rental applicants is sometimes necessary. However, it's crucial to handle this process carefully to avoid potential discrimination lawsuits and other legal issues. Here's a comprehensive guide on how to turn down an applicant properly with solid reasons. 
More Posts